You can’t replace God’s words with your opinion!

Today, we will delve deeply into a topic that has caused much division and misunderstanding within the body of Christ: Replacement Theology. This doctrine posits that the Church has replaced Israel in God’s plan and that the Jewish people are no longer part of His covenantal promises. We will examine this teaching in the light of Scripture, particularly using the Complete Jewish Bible (CJB), to understand why Replacement Theology is not biblical and how the Church can correct this theological error. Additionally, we will explore how historical figures, particularly Emperor Constantine, influenced the development of Replacement Theology.

Understanding Replacement Theology:

Replacement Theology, also known as Supersessionism, asserts that the Church has superseded Israel as God’s chosen people. This theology emerged in the early centuries of Christianity and has been perpetuated by various Church traditions. However, to determine its validity, we must turn to the Word of God.

1. God’s Everlasting Covenant with Israel:

The Bible clearly outlines God’s everlasting covenant with Israel. This covenant is foundational and unchanging.

– Genesis 17:7-8 (CJB): “I am establishing my covenant between me and you, along with your descendants after you, generation after generation, as an everlasting covenant, to be God for you and for your descendants after you. I will give you and your descendants after you the land in which you are now foreigners, all the land of Kena‘an, as a permanent possession; and I will be their God.”

This passage emphasizes the eternal nature of God’s covenant with Abraham and his descendants, the Jewish people. The term “everlasting” (Hebrew: “olam”) signifies a perpetual, unending covenant.

2. The Promises to Israel Are Not Revoked:

Paul, in his letter to the Romans, addresses the continuity of God’s promises to Israel.

– Romans 11:1-2 (CJB): “In that case, I say, isn’t it that God has repudiated his people? Heaven forbid! For I myself am a son of Isra’el, from the seed of Avraham, of the tribe of Binyamin. God has not repudiated his people, whom he chose in advance.”

Paul unequivocally states that God has not rejected His people. The covenant and promises to Israel remain intact.

3. Israel’s Partial Hardening and Future Restoration:

Paul further explains that Israel’s current state of unbelief is partial and temporary.

– Romans 11:25-26 (CJB): “For, brothers, I want you to understand this truth which God formerly concealed but has now revealed, so that you won’t imagine you know more than you actually do. It is that stoniness, to a degree, has come upon Isra’el, until the Gentile world enters in its fullness; and that it is in this way that all Isra’el will be saved. As the Tanakh says, ‘Out of Tziyon will come the Redeemer; he will turn away ungodliness from Ya‘akov.’”

This indicates a future restoration and salvation for Israel, highlighting that God’s plan includes both Jews and Gentiles.

4. The Olive Tree Analogy:

Paul uses the metaphor of an olive tree to describe the relationship between Israel and the Gentiles.

– Romans 11:17-18 (CJB): “But if some of the branches were broken off, and you — a wild olive — were grafted in among them and have become equal sharers in the rich root of the olive tree, then don’t boast as if you were better than the branches! However, if you do boast, remember that you are not supporting the root, the root is supporting you.”

Gentile believers are grafted into the rich heritage of Israel, not as replacements but as fellow participants in God’s promises. This imagery underscores the unity and diversity within God’s family.

5. The Church’s Role and Relationship with Israel:

The Church is called to a special relationship with Israel, characterized by humility and respect.

– Ephesians 2:14-16 (CJB): “For he himself is our shalom — he has made us both one and has broken down the m’chitzah which divided us by destroying in his own body the enmity occasioned by the Torah, with its commands set forth in the form of ordinances. He did this in order to create in union with himself from the two groups a single new humanity and thus make shalom, and in order to reconcile to God both in a single body by being executed on a stake as a criminal and thus in himself killing that enmity.”

Yeshua (Jesus) has made peace between Jews and Gentiles, creating one new humanity in Himself. This unity does not negate the unique identity and role of Israel.

Historical Roots of Replacement Theology: Constantine’s Influence:

Emperor Constantine played a significant role in shaping early Christian thought and practice, particularly regarding the relationship between the Church and Israel. His reign marked a pivotal shift in Christian history, which included the establishment of doctrines and practices that distanced Christianity from its Jewish roots.

1. The Council of Nicaea and Anti-Jewish Sentiment:

In 325 AD, Constantine convened the Council of Nicaea, which was instrumental in formalizing Christian doctrine. One of the outcomes was the separation of Easter from Passover, reflecting an intentional move away from Jewish practices.

– Council of Nicaea, Canon 20: “For it has become a custom for some places to keep Easter with the Jews and others to keep it otherwise. It is our duty to have one unanimous consent about it.”

This decision illustrates a broader trend of minimizing Jewish influence in Christian worship and doctrine, which contributed to the development of Replacement Theology.

2. Constantine’s Edicts and the Marginalization of Jewish Believers:

Constantine’s policies increasingly marginalized Jewish believers and practices. His edicts forbade Christians from observing Jewish customs, reinforcing the idea that Christianity was distinct and separate from Judaism.

– Eusebius, Life of Constantine, Book 3, Chapter 18: “Thus the ordinances of the laws of the Jews have been abolished, together with those of the Samaritans, whom we abominate.”

Such statements and policies further entrenched Replacement Theology by promoting the belief that the Church had replaced Israel.

Refuting Replacement Theology:

1. Misinterpretation of New Testament Texts:

Replacement Theology often arises from misinterpreting New Testament texts. For example, some argue that the Church is the “new Israel” based on certain passages, but a closer examination reveals that these texts do not support such a claim.

– Galatians 3:28-29 (CJB): “There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free man, neither male nor female; for in union with the Messiah Yeshua, you are all one. Also, if you belong to the Messiah, you are seed of Avraham and heirs according to the promise.”

This passage speaks to the unity and equality of believers in Messiah, not the replacement of Israel by the Church. Believers in Yeshua share in the promises to Abraham, but this inclusion does not annul the original promises to Israel.

2. The Role of Israel in Eschatology:

Scripture portrays a significant role for Israel in the end times, affirming that God’s covenant with Israel remains active.

– Zechariah 8:22-23 (CJB): “Yes, many peoples and powerful nations will come to consult Adonai-Tzva’ot in Yerushalayim and to ask Adonai’s favor. Adonai-Tzva’ot says, ‘When that time comes, ten men will take hold — speaking all the languages of the nations — will grab hold of the cloak of a Jew and say, ‘We want to go with you, because we have heard that God is with you.’”

This prophecy underscores the future significance of Israel in God’s plan, where nations will recognize God’s presence with the Jewish people.

3. The Integrity of God’s Character:

God’s faithfulness to Israel is integral to His character. If He were to break His covenant with Israel, it would call into question His faithfulness and reliability.

– Jeremiah 31:35-37 (CJB): “This is what Adonai says, who gives the sun as light for the day, who ordained the laws for the moon and stars to provide light for the night, who stirs up the sea until its waves roar — Adonai-Tzva’ot is his name: ‘If these laws leave my presence,’ says Adonai, ‘then the offspring of Isra’el will stop being a nation in my presence forever.’ This is what Adonai says: ‘If the sky above can be measured and the foundations of the earth be fathomed, then I will reject all the offspring of Isra’el for all that they have done,’ says Adonai.”

This passage affirms the unbreakable nature of God’s covenant with Israel, rooted in His immutable character.

Conclusion: The Church’s Path Forward

To move away from Replacement Theology, the Church must embrace a biblical understanding of God’s covenant with Israel and the Jewish people. Here are practical steps the Church can take:

1. Educate and Teach Biblically:

Church leaders and teachers should provide sound biblical teaching on God’s covenant with Israel, emphasizing the continuity of His promises. Study the Scriptures, especially passages that highlight God’s everlasting covenant with Israel.

2. Foster Relationships with the Jewish Community:

The Church should build genuine relationships with Jewish communities, based on mutual respect and understanding. This includes participating in Jewish-Christian dialogues and supporting the Jewish people.

3. Repent and Renounce Anti-Semitism:

The Church must acknowledge and repent of past and present anti-Semitism and theological errors that have contributed to Replacement Theology. This repentance should be accompanied by concrete actions to combat anti-Semitism within the Church and society.

– 1 John 1:9 (CJB): “If we acknowledge our sins, then, since he is trustworthy and just, he will forgive them and purify us from all wrongdoing.”

Repentance is a necessary step to reconciliation and healing, both within the Church and in its relationship with the Jewish people.

4. Celebrate the Jewish Roots of Christianity:

Recognize and celebrate the Jewish roots of the Christian faith. Which includes learning about and observing God’s Appointed Times because the Bible let’s us know that these are eternal festivals that are for all the generations.  Celebrate Passover over Easter.  Trust me once you do this you will wonder why Christians changed or walked away from these appointed times.  They are not designed as shopping holidays or gift giving times.  They are times to bring you closer to Adonai and take it from me they do. This also includes understanding and honoring the Jewish context of the Bible and the life of Yeshua.

– Romans 9:4-5 (CJB): “They are Israelites; and to them belong the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the giving of the Torah, the temple service, and the promises; the Patriarchs are theirs, and from them, as far as his physical descent is concerned, came the Messiah, who is over all. Praised be Adonai forever! Amen.”

Understanding the Jewish context of our faith enriches our appreciation of God’s plan and our heritage as believers.

5. Pray for Israel:

Regularly pray for the peace of Jerusalem and for the salvation and well-being of the Jewish people.

– Psalm 122:6 (CJB): “Pray for shalom in Yerushalayim; may those who love you prosper.”

Prayer aligns our hearts with God’s purposes and fosters a deeper love for Israel.

6. Emphasize Unity in Diversity:

The Church should emphasize the unity of believers in Yeshua while respecting and valuing the diversity of its members, including Jewish believers.

– Ephesians 4:4-6 (CJB): “There is one body and one Spirit, just as when you were called you were called to one hope. And there is one Lord, one trust, one immersion, and one God, the Father of all, who rules over all, works through all and is in all.”

Unity in the body of Messiah does not mean uniformity; it means embracing and celebrating the diversity within the community of faith.

7. Teach and Model Humility:

The Church must teach and model humility, recognizing that Gentile believers are grafted into the rich heritage of Israel and not superior to the natural branches.

– Romans 11:20-21 (CJB): “True, but so what? They were broken off because of their lack of trust. However, you keep your place only because of your trust. So don’t be arrogant; on the contrary, be terrified! For if God did not spare the natural branches, he certainly won’t spare you!”

Humility is essential in fostering healthy relationships and honoring God’s original covenant with Israel.

In closing, let us remember Paul’s words in Romans 11:18 (CJB): “…you are not supporting the root, the root is supporting you.” As the Church, we are called to support and honor the root—Israel—through whom the Messiah came and through whom God’s promises continue to unfold.

To move forward from Replacement Theology, we must return to the Scriptures and embrace the full counsel of God’s Word. We must educate ourselves and others about the everlasting covenant with Israel, foster genuine relationships with the Jewish community, repent of anti-Semitism, celebrate our Jewish roots, pray for Israel, emphasize unity in diversity, and model humility.

By doing so, we align ourselves with God’s purposes and participate in His grand narrative of redemption that includes both Jews and Gentiles. May we, as the body of Messiah, stand firm in biblical truth, rejecting Replacement Theology and embracing God’s unchanging covenant with Israel. Amen.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *